- High-quality toilet paper should be gentle and clean up messes without leaving anything behind.
- Charmin Ultra Strong Toilet Paper is soft, easy to tear, and stays strong when wet and dry.
Everyone seems to have a toilet paper brand that they remain loyal to. After all, if you’re going to apply the toilet paper “where the sun don’t shine,” you want it to treat you right.
Below, we rounded up tissue that is right for your comfort, budget, and shopping preferences. We also included the available roll quantities in a breakout box so you can customize how much you’d like to have on hand.
For additional advice on choosing the right toilet paper, plus tips for shopping for toilet paper online, scroll to the bottom of this guide.
Here is the best toilet paper of 2021
- Best toilet paper overall: Charmin Ultra Strong Toilet Paper
- Best sustainable toilet paper: Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Toilet Paper
- Best budget toilet paper: Scott 1,000 Sheets Per Roll Toilet Paper
- Best toilet paper for sensitive skin: Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care Toilet Paper
- Best toilet paper subscription: Reel Premium Bamboo Toilet Paper
- Best three-ply toilet paper: Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper
Charmin’s Ultra Strong Toilet Paper is plush, strong, easy to tear, ultra-absorbent, and has built a faithful following with its consistent quality.
Pros: Soft, strong when wet and dry, rips cleanly from the roll, woven like a washcloth, Roto-Rooter-approved
Cons: Slow to dissolve
You might recognize Charmin Ultra Strong Toilet Paper from the series of commercials featuring bears with comfortable butts. As the name suggests, Ultra Strong is positioned as Charmin’s strongest two-ply toilet paper. Charmin advertises it as having washcloth-like cleaning abilities with four times the strength of “the leading bargain brand” when wet.
This durable and absorbent toilet paper is useful when your digestive system is having an off day and trips to the bathroom are frequent. And, if you’re concerned about a hardy toilet paper wreaking havoc on your plumbing, you’ll take comfort in knowing that Ultra Strong is Roto-Rooter-approved as septic- and clog-safe.
Though it’s strong whether wet or dry — and neatly rips from the roll —, the downside is that it takes a while to dissolve. That said, it might not be the best toilet paper for super finicky plumbing.
The best sustainable toilet paper
If you’re looking for an affordable toilet paper that gets the job done and is wonderful for our planet, Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Toilet Paper is a quality option.
Pros: 100% recycled; bleach-free; no added dyes, inks, or fragrances; Rainforest Alliance-certified, sewer- and septic-safe
Cons: Not as soft as other options
Seventh Generation is known for producing eco-friendly household items that won’t break the bank, and the company’s 100% Recycled 2-Ply Toilet Paper is no exception. It’s Rainforest Alliance-certified, too, which means it was produced with social, economic, and environmental sustainability practices in mind.
This two-ply, minimum 50% post-consumer recycled fiber toilet paper is free of fragrances, inks, and dyes, so it’s a good option for sensitive skin. Because the toilet paper is unbleached, there’s much less water and energy used in the manufacturing process. Plus, it’s safe for sewer systems, septic systems, and low-flow toilets, like those found in campers and RVs.
Though it’s not as plush as other options, Seventh Generation is great for your bathroom if you’re looking to limit your carbon footprint.
The best budget toilet paper
Scott’s 1,000 Sheets Per Roll Toilet Paper is ideal for people who want to save money, care about the environment, and don’t like lint.
Pros: Affordable, eco-friendly, dissolves easily, minimal lint
Cons: Somewhat abrasive
Despite Scott’s 1,000 Sheets Per Roll Toilet Paper‘s one-ply stature and quick-to-dissolve design, it stays strong and leaves behind little lint. It’s what we use in our house and Scott is a great, sustainable option that’s certified by the Forest Stewardship Council, too. Scott 1,000 dissolves quickly and easily while maintaining strength while wet. It’s also recommended for people with RVs and sensitive septic tanks who aren’t looking for luxury — it breaks down quickly but is still rough on the skin.
The best toilet paper for sensitive skin
If most toilet papers leave a burning sensation in your rear after a thorough cleaning, consider treating yourself with Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care Toilet Paper, which is triple-thick and hypoallergenic.
Pros: Soft, made with plant-based fibers, hypoallergenic, paraben-free, made without harsh chemicals and dyes, sustainably sourced, certified by the Forest Stewardship Council, three times thicker and two times more absorbent than the average brand, biodegradable, clog-free, septic- and sewer-safe
Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care Toilet Paper has a cushion-like, rippled texture, which is supposed to clean better while remaining comfortable, strong, and soft. It’s ideal for sensitive skin because it’s hypoallergenic, paraben-free, and made without harsh chemicals and dyes.
Cottonelle’s toilet paper is also sustainably sourced and certified by the Forest Stewardship Council. And, because this two-ply tissue is three times thicker and two times more absorbent per sheet than the average brand, you’ll appreciate its ultra-plush feel.
Cottonelle is also biodegradable, clog-free, and septic- and sewer-safe so, even though it’s a thicker toilet paper, it’s just as safe to use as it is soft.
The best toilet paper subscription
If you never want to run out of toilet paper ever again, the Reel Premium Bamboo Toilet Paper ships right to your door and is made without trees.
Pros: Tree-free, zero plastic packaging (including tape), no inks or dyes, fragrance- and chlorine-free, BPA-free, biodegradable, good quality weight and thickness, impressive sheet count per roll
Sure, subscription services are typical for makeup, coffee, and even razors, but toilet paper? That’s a new one. The Reel Premium Bamboo Toilet Paper makes sustainably sourced, tree-free toilet paper that will be regularly shipped to you — so you never run out.
This three-ply toilet paper is sustainably sourced and made without chlorine, fragrance, inks, and dyes. Zero plastic goes into the manufacturing process and the 100% bamboo rolls are wrapped with recycled paper.
You can subscribe and have Reel delivered to you every month, every two months, or every three months, depending on how stocked you want your bathroom cabinet to be. If you want to reduce waste wherever you can, these rolls are a wonderful option.
The best three-ply toilet paper
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper is the ideal absorbent tissue if softness is your top concern.
Pros: Incredibly soft and absorbent, thick, Sustainable Forestry Initiative-certified, sewer- and septic-safe
Cons: Produces lint, not the best for weak plumbing
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper lives up to its name, as its three-layered paper makes it more absorbent and softer than one- and two-layered sheets.
The Sustainable Forestry Initiative-certified toilet paper remains strong, though it doesn’t dissolve easily. But, despite the thick texture, it’s sewer- and septic-safe.
Quilted Northern guarantees that their rolls will fit your holder. If the rolls don’t fit, the company will send you a free extender.
Tips for buying toilet paper
How to compare toilet paper prices
There is no standardization of toilet paper square or roll sizes, so words like “mega roll” or “double roll” don’t mean much. Instead, if you want to compare prices, look at the cost per square foot and the number of “ply,” or layers of thickness. This scary-looking yet simple equation should do the trick:
(Price in dollars x 14400) ÷ (width of each sheet in inches x length of each sheet in inches x number of sheets on a roll x number of rolls) = cost in cents per square foot
And, when looking at costs, you should keep in mind that you will use fewer sheets of three-ply than one-ply because of the superior cleaning and absorbing abilities.
Less toilet paper is better
Although there are plenty of eco-friendly alternatives on the market, for the sake of forests and our environment, the less toilet paper you use, the better.
One way to use less toilet paper is to install a bidet. We have a helpful guide on the best bidets, but basically, you can get a decent bidet on Amazon for less than $100 and install it yourself in about half an hour. You’ll still need toilet paper to spot-check the bidet’s work and to dry off, but you’ll use much less.
A note about buying toilet paper online
As we were doing our research, we found that there were a lot of buyer complaints about the rolls they ordered not being the same size as what they were used to. For this reason, when buying online, pay special attention to the sizes of the sheets, how many sheets are on a roll, and how many rolls you are getting.
If you do find a toilet paper you like on Amazon, we recommend trying the “Subscribe & Save” service. This allows you to save up to 15% off the regular price. Plus, you don’t have to remember to reorder toilet paper. It automatically comes to your home at regular intervals, much like our Reel pick.
We examined hundreds of expert and buyer reviews and ratings of many toilet paper brands and styles. The ones we chose to include in our guide have the ability to clean you down there, are septic- and sewer system-safe, and have discernable softness.
Check out our other bathroom guides