When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
MILAN, ITALY – JANUARY 17: Alexandra Hasan poses wearing an Urban Outfitters jacket on January 17, 2015 in Milan, Italy. (Photo by Vanni Bassetti/Getty Images)
Vanni Bassetti/Getty Images
Winter is here and that means you’ll likely need a warm and dependable coat.
The best coats of the season include trenches, wool overcoats, teddys, and faux leather styles.
Shop 30+ of the best coats on the market in a range of silhouettes and price points.
Now that Winter 2021 has made its debut, it may be time to think about procuring a new coat for the season. Our top choices for coats are ones that can work for varying conditions. They include sleek vegan leather pieces and timeless trenches which are especially helpful during a windy forecast, as well as extra fuzzy teddy styles or puffers for when temperatures really plummet.
Organized by style, the options in this guide are undeniably practical but also showcase the latest trends and most comfortable fabrics in a wide range of price points. Ahead, explore all the best coats we predict you’ll look forward to tossing on until spring makes its return next year.
Here are the best winter coats for women in 2021:
Trench coats
Henning
Due to their classic silhouette and typically not-too-heavy weight, trenches are considered an any-season piece of outerwear and ideal for transitional weather. The camel hue is timeless — and truly does complement anything it’s paired with — but feel free to branch out into other versatile shades such as army green or navy blue. Even try a fresh interpretation with leather detailing on the trench coat’s signature waist tie. The options are quite limitless — each of them perfect for layering with your favorite knitwear as the temperatures drop.
The ultimate no-nonsense winter coat is the puffer. Embrace the plush texture and often less-shape-defining silhouette (though, some come with belts) in this sporty, practical, and undeniably insulated option. Because the puffer is also a very classic and traditional winter style, you’ll find tons of interpretations from luxury labels to affordable brands.
Slick, sophisticated, and friendly to animals, vegan leather alternatives have skyrocketed in the past few years. Today the faux leather coat is one of the market’s most desirable options, with finishes that look buttery smooth and luxe, regardless of their price. You can’t go wrong with a classic black option that adds a little edge to any ensemble, but beautiful shades of green and tan are also great for wearing now and well into early spring, too.
In single- and double-breasted options, the wool overcoat takes cues from classic menswear with a boxier shape. Available in a range of lengths — anywhere from just under the bum to sweeping the floor — this evergreen coat silhouette can suit tons of different styles and outfits. For instance, toss a sharp wool coat over a sweatsuit for an elevated errand-running ensemble or drape it over your favorite blazer to head to the office on a chilly weekend.
The quilted coat is the puffer’s lightweight cousin that’s incredibly on-trend for fall and winter in 2021. Another great transitional piece of outerwear, quilted styles can take on the appearance of coat liners or a handmade piece by your family’s own craft master. Either way, the style features diamond-shaped seaming that’ll help keep you warm while you wear it.
The timeless wrap style offers the cozy feel of a wool overcoat with the cinched silhouette of a trench — the best of both worlds, if you will. In collarless and wide-collar options, this style offers some versatility as you can wear it open and loose or keep multiple layers neatly in place on your frame with the coat’s waistline tie.
For the highly tactile crowd, there’s no more satisfying coat than the teddy. Made of plush shearling or faux furs, this style is slightly oversized no matter what silhouette you choose. It’s also a coat option that’s innately statement-making. Feel free to allow your ensemble to remain pared-back and simplistic as any of these teddy coats pack quite a punch, while keeping you toasty, too.
Often made from heavy double-faced wool or cushy cotton, this coat has an easy-to-wear silhouette. What stands out most is its generous and dramatic shawl collar, which adds a special element to every ensemble and, ultimately, brings attention to your face.
When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
Our top picks for the best kids winter coats include styles from Patagonia, Amazon, L.L.Bean, Columbia, and Buckle Me Baby.
Hillary Grigonis/Insider
Kids lose body heat faster than adults. But kids can also generate more body heat by moving around and playing — something that’s hard to do when bundled in too many bulky layers. That’s why the best winter coats for kids are warm yet also lightweight and durable enough to withstand an entire winter of active play.
Linda McGurk, author of “No Such Thing As Bad Weather,” says she looks for versatile coats that work for many winter activities. “I look for durability and function first of all — an all-around jacket that can be used for a lot of different types of winter activities and works for school,” she said. “The outside must protect against the weather even during harsh conditions and rough outdoor play.”
To find the best kids winter coats, I talked to three outdoor experts and a nationally certified child passenger safety instructor. I then researched the top-ranked winter coats that offered warmth, moisture resistance, durability, comfort, and, for babies and toddlers, car seat safety. Price, of course, is a consideration for many families. I chose coats over $100 only if they offer more than one season of wear with excellent durability and extendable sleeves.
Best kids winter coat overall: Patagonia 4-in-1 Everyday Jacket, $169 on Patagonia Its versatile, durable design means the Patagonia 4-in-1 Everyday Jacket is the only coat that most kids need year-round.
Best kids fleece-lined coat: L.L.Bean Down Jacket, $99 on L.L.Bean The L.L.Bean Down Jacket is a well-insulated down puffer that’s a great choice for kids who have a tendency to get cold fast and in areas with harsh winters.
Best kids ski jacket: Patagonia Snowshot Jacket, $199 on Patagonia The incredibly lightweight Patagonia Snowshot Jacket will keep kids warm and dry without hindering their movement.
Best winter coat for toddlers: Buckle Me Baby Toasty, from $59.99 on Amazon The Buckle Me Baby Toasty is a warm winter coat without the collar and hood that many toddlers don’t like and, thanks to its unique design, it’s car-seat friendly.
Pros: Winter coat, lightweight jacket, and raincoat in one; durable outer shell; weather-sealed zippers; warm insulation; lightweight design
Cons: Girls version lacks chest pocket
The Patagonia 4-in-1 Everyday Jacket is a pricey option, but it’s the only coat kids need year-round and should last older kids at least two years thanks to its extendable sleeves and durable design. When my 9-year-old daughter wore this coat on a fishing trip in 40-degree windy weather, she outlasted the adult on the boat without a complaint.
Many 3-in-1 and 4-in-1 coats use a basic fleece inner layer without any waterproofing. But, in addition to the Patagonia 4-in-1’s waterproof polyester exterior, the removable inner jacket is also finished with a water-resistant taffeta.
With both layers combined, the coat has adjustable cuffs and an inner drawstring at the waist to keep snow out as well as a full hood and warm collar. The interior jacket, when worn alone, also functions great as a rain jacket and a spring or fall coat. This jacket uses a warmer, comfortable shearling pile fleece that can be worn facing inside or out, which is what makes this coat a 4-in-1 instead of a 3-in-1.
Of note, we tested the boys version, but the girls size has a softer high-pile fleece lining, lacks the chest pocket, and has a different seam style. When it is time to size up, Patagonia also has a trade-in program to get a new discounted jacket.
Pros: Well-insulated, waterproof, cuff with thumbhole, snow collar, lots of colors and patterns
Cons: Only partial fleece lining, not as durable or versatile as a 3-in-1 or 4-in-1 coat
I spent hours researching coats under $50 that were both warm and waterproof. Many didn’t look warm or had questionable durability — others had fewer features and less insulation in the girls versions. The Amazon Essentials Heavy-Weight Hooded Puffer is a fleece-lined puffy coat that has lots of insulation, plus features like wrist cuffs and a snow collar.
Overall, I was impressed with this coat for how little it costs. It’s not quite as warm as some pricier options, but still seems warm enough for snow play. The puffer consists of a polyester exterior with synthetic polyester insulation. Part of the interior torso area is lined with fleece. The areas below the snow collar and inside the sleeves are lined with a polyester material similar to the exterior.
While all puffy coats have a tendency to rip more easily than ski jackets and all-in-one coats, this budget coat has so far survived tree-climbing and rough play unscathed. My daughter says it has kept her warm in the fall weather that we’ve had so far, including a 40-degree windy day. Pricier coats with more insulation will be a bit warmer. I preferred the L.L.Bean Down Jacket’s warmer insulation and fuzzy soft lining.
There are several different colors and patterns to choose from. In fact, this coat is my 6-year-old’s favorite, largely because it comes in her favorite pattern and color: pink cheetah.
The L.L.Bean Down Jacket Colorblock is a well-insulated down puffer that’s a great choice for kids who have a tendency to get cold fast and in areas with harsh winters.
Pros: Very warm, comfortable, lightweight, gender neutral
Cons: Not as durable and versatile as an all-in-one coat
Ginny Yurich, founder of the 1000 Hours Outside movement, says that down is nature’s best insulator, but it can’t trap heat once wet. The L.L.Bean Down Jacket Colorblock, however, is filled with treated down that doesn’t absorb moisture so the coat insulates very well, even in wet conditions. It kept my daughter warm on a school field trip even with on-and-off misty rain.
The Colorblock seemed to be the warmest of all the puffy coats that we tested. The down fill is paired with a high-pile fleece lining. My daughter, who refuses to wear stiff materials like jeans, says that the coat is very comfortable. It also has nice soft cuffs that cover part of the hand to help keep snow and cold out.
The downsides to this coat are true for every puffer coat: The exterior fabric isn’t as durable and it’s not as versatile as an all-in-one coat. But, the coat has so far held up nicely, without tears or stains. With real down inside, the coat will also occasionally shed small feathers, particularly after a wash.
The Colorblock is a unisex design and is available in purple, blue, or yellow, with toddler, little kid, and big kid sizes available.
The incredibly lightweight Patagonia Snowshot Jacket will keep kids warm and dry without hindering their movement.
Pros: Lightweight insulation, water-resistant, removable hood, media and ski pass pockets
Cons: Expensive
The Patagonia Snowshot is great for active kids in need of a lightweight coat. When I first pulled it out of the box, it felt more like a spring jacket — despite its 150g polyester insulation and durable waterproof shell.
That lightweight insulation without the loft of a down coat makes the Snowshot comfortable for both the slopes and active outdoor play. And my 9-year-old had no complaints about the cold while wearing this coat. We tested the boys version, but there is a girls version, which is called the Snowbelle.
Like the 4-in-1, the Snowshot feels very durable, down to the nice moisture-sealing around the zipper. To keep wind and snow out of the sleeves, the Snowshot has soft cuffs with a thumb hole and a snow collar that buttons around the waist. It also has well-thought-out pockets, including a top pocket with an opening for headphones and a ski pass pocket on one sleeve. The removable hood has a second elastic layer that helps keep it from falling down.
When it comes to the downsides, this is just a winter coat. The expense of the 4-in-1, which has a softer lining but is heavier, is easier to justify. The Snowshot does, however, have Grow Fit, so you can snip a seam and make the sleeves 2 inches longer, and it is eligible for Patagonia’s trade-in program.
The Buckle Me Baby Toasty is a warm winter coat without the collar and hood that many toddlers don’t like and, thanks to its unique design, it’s car-seat friendly.
Pros: Car seat friendly, no collar or hood for picky toddlers, warm, waterproof
Cons: Velcro doesn’t always stay put, less warm due to lack of collar
Bulky winter coats and car seats don’t mix — pediatrician Alisa Baer, a nationally certified child passenger safety instructor, says coats can introduce as much as 3 to 4 inches of extra slack in a harness. The Buckle Me Baby Toasty Car Seat Coat eliminates the hassle of removing and putting on a toddler’s coat every time you travel by car. Its unique design means the entire front and shoulders of the coat are outside of the car seat straps; the only part of the coat in the seat is the back panel.
The coat, which is made with fleece, polyester insulation, and a water-resistant exterior, was actually warmer than I expected — it kept my toddler warm while he played in 40-degree weather. When worn with an extra layer underneath, I expect this coat will be warm enough for snow play in colder temperatures.
A downside for some: Because the coat lacks a collar and hood, it offers less protection against the cold. But I actually prefer this because my toddler doesn’t tolerate collars and hoods. My biggest complaint about this coat is that the velcro at the shoulders didn’t always stay closed, especially when my toddler protested wearing it.
If you will not be using the coat in a car seat, we recommend our pick for the best fleece-lined coat, the L.L.Bean Down Jacket, which is very warm and lightweight.
The Columbia Tiny Bear II Bunting covers infants head to toe in warm fleece and, in many cases, is safe for the car seat.
Pros: Built-in gloves and booties, car seat safe when sized appropriately, cute animal hood, head-to-toe coverage, affordable
Cons: No water resistance, not heavy enough for extended snow play
I first tried the Columbia Tiny Bear II Bunting as a car-seat-safe layer when my son was an infant, but its convenience extends beyond the car seat. Although the bunting is thin, it covers the baby from head to toe to provide warmth. With built-in booties and gloves, you don’t even have to put shoes on pre-walkers.
The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends a thin, snug-fitting fleece layer to keep infants warm in the car without the dangerous bulk of a winter coat. However, it’s essential to note that any outer layer worn in a car seat should be properly fitted and tested to ensure safety. Read more about how to test a coat for car seat safety at the end of this article.
Besides being thin and warm, the Tiny Bear II Bunting’s fleece also feels very comfortable. The material washed well and didn’t stain when muddied. And the bear ears on the hood are just adorable.
Although this a great coat for running errands with a baby, the bunting isn’t made for extended wear in below-freezing temperatures or for playing in the snow. But, since most pre-walkers aren’t sitting in the snow or spending long periods outdoors in cold weather, we prioritized car seat safety.
For longer stretches outdoors, the Tiny Bear Bunting II makes a great base layer under a heavier coat. If you are looking for a coat, I love the Primary Baby Puffer Suit, which still has the fold-over mittens and booties but is thicker than others, making it less ideal for use in a car seat.
What else we’ve tested
Hillary Grigonis/Insider
I’m currently testing 10 different kids winter coats with my 9-year-old, 6-year-old, and 2-year-old. As my kids spend more time playing in each one, our picks may change. But, for the initial few weeks of use, these coats didn’t quite make it to the top:
Columbia Whirlibird II: This ski jacket is lightweight and waterproof. With 80g of insulation, it’s not as warm as our top pick and my daughter thought it felt a little too stiff. It is a durable option that’s a bit more affordable than the Snowshot.
Primary Baby Puffer Suit: This is a great choice if you plan to take your infant out in the cold for long stretches of time. It’s warm but lightweight enough for them to move in and includes fold-over booties and mittens. However, it’s not the best choice for use in a car seat.
All in Motion Short Puffer Jacket: My son really likes the boys version of this jacket. It’s affordable and still fairly warm. I love that it has built-in glove clips. However, the girls version isn’t identical and reviewers have complained that the bell-shaped waist lets in cold air.
The North Face Snowquest Triclimate: 3-in-1 coats are great for toddlers because the inner jacket tends to be car seat safe. My son liked this coat and it’s nicely weather-sealed. The only insulation is the double-sided fleece jacket, however. It’s also pricey for this age group.
Our kids winter coats testing methodology
I spent a month testing 10 coats with my three kids, ages 9, 6, and 2, in fall in Michigan. These coats were tested during rough and dirty play, including climbing trees, fishing, school recess, and trekking through a muddy pumpkin patch. I’m continuing to test each coat throughout the winter as snow falls and temperatures dip. Here are the tests we’ve completed:
Waterproofing: I gave each coat several sprays from a water bottle at the zipper area to see how the coat may stand up to rain and melting snow.
Warmth: These coats were tested in weather in the mid-40s, sometimes with a lower windchill. Testing will continue in lower temperatures as winter hits.
Comfort: Can the child move around easily in this coat? Is it too stiff or bulky? These were questions that I considered during the first few weeks with these coats.
Car seat safety: Would the coat follow our pediatrician’s guidelines for a car seat safety? The toddler and infant categories were checked for fit inside of a rear-facing harness car seat.
As testing continues, I will also be considering:
Warmth: I will test these in snowy conditions and below freezing temperatures.
Durability: All 10 of these coats held up well during the first month of use and one or two washes. I will continue to inspect the coats for tears and signs of wear.
How to choose a winter coat for a child
A child’s smaller body loses heat faster than adults. But, on the flip side, a child that’s actively playing in the snow may generate more body heat and be warmer than an adult who’s simply supervising the fun. So, how do parents determine how many layers a child needs to stay warm? What should parents look for when choosing a coat for kids? When shopping for a child’s winter coat, consider the materials, design, warmth, waterproofing, layers, and fit.
Materials: A coat’s materials play a big role in how much heat is retained. The ideal material is warm, but doesn’t make a coat that is too bulky to play in. McGurk prefers synthetic down alternatives that hold heat well, unlike down which loses the ability to hold heat when wet. What a coat is not made from is also important. McGurk recommends coats with water-repellant coatings that do not contain perfluorochemicals (PFCs). PFCs do not break down in the environment, and lab animals exposed to large doses experienced adverse effects, according to a CDC fact sheet.
Design: The design of the coat is also essential to consider. Winter coats for children tend to fall into one of these categories:
A puffy coat is light and easy to play in, but it needs to be paired with an outer shell, such as a rain jacket, in order to be waterproof. An outer shell will also protect the coat from tearing, which is common with puffy coats.
Three-in-one coats have a warm inner layer, often made of fleece or polyester, and a waterproof outer layer. Both layers can be worn at once for winter play, while the inner jacket works well for cool fall days and the outer jacket can be worn alone as a raincoat or windbreaker.
Other winter coats are designed as a single garment consisting of both a waterproof outer layer and insulation for warmth. These coats are less versatile but may be easier for young children to zip than 3-in-1’s with their multiple zippers.
Warmth and waterproofing: Always consider the climate the coat will be worn in. For wet, cold winters, McGurk says a waterproof, windproof coat is a must. The colder the climate is, the more insulation parents will want to look for. For all climates, a coat that’s breathable will help keep active kids from overheating.
Layers: Coats for outdoor play should have enough room for layers underneath. In the coldest temperatures, winter coats work best with layers. For babies and younger children who are unable or unlikely to tell you if they are too warm or hot, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends using one more layer than an adult would be comfortable in. Yurich recommends using merino wool as a base layer — it is warm but wicks away sweat.
Fit: Parents should also consider how a coat fits. A well-fitting coat will allow a child to move around and play. If the sleeves are creep up on the wrists, the coat is too small, McGurk says. If the sleeves cover the hands, the coat is too big. Some coats have a clever extend-to-size feature, which allows you to snip some stitching to make the sleeves longer. Both McGurk and Yurich say they tend to go up one size to get two or more seasons out of a coat and to allow enough room for layers underneath. Sizing up can also help make the cost of a coat more reasonable.
Winter coats and car seat safety
Parents should never size up when looking for a coat that’s safe to wear in a car seat. A large, thick coat can create as many as 3 to 4 inches of extra slack in the car seat straps. This increases the chances of injury in a car crash, explains Alisa Baer, cofounder of car seat safety advocacy organization The Car Seat Lady and a nationally certified child passenger safety instructor. The force of a car crash takes all the extra puff out of a coat. When that happens, the car seat straps or seat belt that once looked snug no longer fit properly and the child may move more in an accident or even slip out of the restraints.
To determine if a coat is safe for a car seat harness, use Baer’s Chalk Test (you can follow along with this video). With the child wearing the coat, buckle them into the seat and properly tighten the straps. Use a piece of chalk and mark where the tail strap — the strap that you pull to tighten the harness — comes out of the seat. Then remove the coat and buckle the child, tightening only to the chalk line. If you can pinch the straps or fit more than one finger underneath, then the coat is too bulky and should not be worn in the car seat.
Older children and even adults are also safest without buckling a seat belt over a bulky coat, Baer says. In the front seat, a belt tensioner locks in a crash, pulling the belt tight against the body. That removes the tension from the strap. However, most back seats do not have a belt tensioner, so coats will introduce extra slack. Even with a belt tensioner, all seat belts will work better without an overly large coat, Baer says.
Of course, cold is dangerous to a child as well, but the American Academy of Pediatrics says that a thin, snug-fitting coat such as a fleece jacket can be both safe in a crash and in the cold. A thin jacket along with a hat and gloves can keep a child warm when walking from the car to a building. Layering with a long-sleeve onesie and fleece leggings also helps, Baer says. Bring a warm winter coat to slip on over the fleece jacket for outdoor play or in the event the car breaks down.
Our sources
Alisa Baer, pediatrician, cofounder of car seat safety advocacy organization The Car Seat Lady, and a nationally certified child passenger safety instructor
The human body loses heat rapidly in cold temperatures, a process that begins when the ambient temperature falls below 68 degrees. This type of heat reduction accounts for about 65% of total warmth lost, and because children are smaller than adults, they are even more susceptible to over-cooling. The right winter coat can maintain a core temperature. For kids, the best winter coat also needs to be versatile enough to wear from recess to snowball fights.
To narrow down our selections for the best winter coats for kids, we consulted with two outdoor experts – Linda McGurk, the author of “No Such Thing As Bad Weather” and 1000 Hours Outside founder Ginny Yurich – and pediatrician Alisa Baer. Then we researched coats to see which ranked highest according to our selection criteria at the end of this guide. The kids winter coats featured here will help your child maintain core warmth and are available in many sizes and colors to accommodate plenty of age groups and kids’ preferences.
With a detachable shell and liner, theColumbia Whirlibird II Interchange Jacketis a three-in-one coat so your child will be ready for both the coldest and mildest of winter days.
Columbia’s children’s apparel offers the same high level of quality as the brand’s gear designed for adults. The Whirlibird II Interchange Jacket is made of a waterproof, wind-breaking shell and an insulated inner jacket. The two pieces are attached with zippers and be worn together or alone. Together, they provide enough warmth for playing in the snow, going on long walks, and for making the trip to and from school on cold wintry days.
On its own, the coast’s shell is great for milder, wet days. The insulated inner jacket looks and functions just like a puffer coat and is warm enough on its own for days when the temperatures are cool but not frigid.
The inner jacket’s warmth is provided by a synthetic fill and also through Columbia’s patented Omni-Heat Reflective system, which consists of a pattern of metallic dots that reflect radiated heat back toward the body. The outer jacket is waterproof but still breathable and releases excess heat and moisture that builds up from sweat.
With Columbia’s Outgrown system, parents can snip a few seams to extend the length of the sleeves. This can help the coat last through growth spurts and even multiple seasons.
Shop all kids winter coats and gear from Columbia and Amazon
Cons: Occasional sizing issues, outer shell for waterproofing not included
Most kids grow so fast that they will only get a single season out of a piece of clothing. But when it comes to winter coats, you still need a jacket that will keep your child warm regardless of price. Enter the super affordable Amazon Essentials Lightweight Packable Puffer.
The coat has a polyester down-alternative fill insulation and a smooth nylon lining to provide warmth and comfort. But, while this puffer jacket will keep your child warm on milder days when layered over a T-shirt or sweater, it’s necessary to add a waterproof shell to keep a child warm and dry in cold, wet weather. The coat’s elasticized cuffs and hood also add to the jacket’s warmth preservation.
When not in use, the coat packs down into an included stuff sack. The Amazon Essentials Lightweight Packable Puffer comes in multiple colors, too.
Pros: Reversible design, soft and warm fleece lining, exterior repels water
Cons: Sizing sometimes runs small
Parents will love the super-soft lining of The North Face Mossbud Swirl Reversible Jacket as much as their kids inevitably do because this soft, cuddly coat is one that kids will love to wear. The high pile fleece and insulated fill provide plenty of warmth, while the exterior repels light rain and snow and reduces wind chill.
Even the exterior of the coat is soft and comfortable, since it’s designed to be worn in reverse, too. That reversible design gives kids more flexibility fashion-wise, while both materials — the fleece and the water-resistant taffeta — play a role in performance.
And like any good kids garment should be, the Mossbud Swirl Reversible Jacket is machine washable. Just be sure to note the sizing with care to ensure a proper fit.
Shop all The North Face kids winter coats at Amazon and
The best ski jacket
Patagonia
While Patagonia Snowshot Jacketwas designed for use on the slopes, it’s a versatile jacket for outdoor play, family outings, and walks to school.
The ski pass pocket built into the sleeve of the Patagonia Snowshot Jacket is a tipoff as to the design of this winter coat. It was made for use by kids carving their way down snowy slopes. As such, it can handle the cold that comes with everyday winter wear extremely well, and without that bulky puffy parka fit that so many ski coats have.
The Snowshot has a durable water-repellent shell that features taped seams for excellent wind-resistance. The inner layer is soft thanks to a polyester plain-weave lining and warm 150 gram down alternative fill. A drop tail hem offers extra protection against wind and precipitation, while the hood can be cinched down tight around the face when the weather is frigid or it can be removed entirely for milder days.
While the Patagonia Snowshot is a pricey jacket, it might last for more than one season. The sleeves have a “grow-fit” feature that allows them to be extended (or retracted) by as much as 2 inches.
Pros: Warm, soft materials; perfect for layering; cute animal-themed hood; car seat-safe when sized appropriately
Cons: No water resistance, not heavy enough for extended snow play
While infants won’t start a snowball fight, they do need to stay warm when heading out the door. The Columbia Tiny Bear II Bunting is more than just a coat — its built-in gloves, hat, and boots make it quick and simple to get baby dressed to go outdoors. I used a previous version of this bunting on my youngest before he began to walk and I loved that I could keep him warm without needing to put snow boots on him.
Most bulky winter coats are not safe in a car seat, but Columbia’s fleece jackets and buntings are thin and snug enough that most parents will find they pass the car seat fit test. The Tiny Bear is made from a thin fleece that, when sized appropriately, is car-seat-friendly. Parents should ensure the bunting fits snugly and perform the chalk test, which is explained at the end of this guide.
The attached pants, hood, and fold-over booties, and gloves make the bunting warmer than just a thin fleece jacket alone. While the Tiny Bear will keep the baby warm while traveling and running errands, parents in colder climates will want to pair it with a heavier jacket if spending extended time in the cold. It’s warm enough for walking from the car into the grocery store, for example, but not for spending an hour hunting for the perfect Christmas tree in the snow. The thin material, however, makes it great for layering — you don’t need to remove the bunting before adding a bulky winter coat. The bunting was the coat my toddler wore most often last winter. I simply added a puffy jacket for winter walks and outdoor activities.
A child’s smaller body loses heat faster than adults. But, on the flip side, a child that’s actively playing in the snow may generate more body heat and be warmer than an adult who’s simply supervising the fun. So, how do parents determine how many layers a child needs to stay warm? What should parents look for when choosing a coat for kids? When shopping for a child’s winter coat, consider the materials, design, warmth, waterproofing, layers, and fit.
Materials: A coat’s materials play a big role in how much heat is retained. The ideal material is warm, yet makes a coat that isn’t too bulky to play in. McGurk prefers synthetic down alternatives that hold heat well, even when wet. Although down holds heat well, it loses the ability to hold heat when it’s wet. What a coat is not made from is also important. McGurk recommends coats with water-repellant coatings that do not contain perfluorochemicals (PFCs). PFCs do not break down in the environment, and lab animals exposed to large doses experienced adverse effects, according to a CDC fact sheet.
Design: The design of the coat is also essential to consider. Winter coats for children tend to fall in one of these categories:
A puffy coat is light and easy to play in, but it needs to be paired with an outer shell, such as a rain jacket, in order to be waterproof. An outer shell will also protect the coat from tearing, which is common with puffy coats.
Three-in-one coats use a warm inner layer, often made of fleece or polyester, and a waterproof outer layer. Both layers can be worn at once for winter play, while the inner jacket works well for cool fall days and the outer jacket can be worn without the inner layer as a raincoat or windbreaker.
Other winter coats are designed as a single garment consisting of both a waterproof outer layer and insulation for warmth. These coats are less versatile than the three-in-ones but may be easier to zip since the multiple zippers of three-in-ones can confuse younger children.
Warmth and waterproofing: Always consider the climate the coat will be worn in. For wet, cold winters, McGurk says a waterproof, windproof coat is a must. The colder the climate is, the more insulation parents will want to look for. For all climates, a coat that’s breathable will help keep active kids from overheating.
Layers: Coats for outdoor play should have enough room for layers underneath. In the coldest temperatures, winter coats work best with layers. For babies and younger children who are unable or unlikely to tell you if they are too warm or hot, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends using one more layer than an adult would be comfortable in. Yurich recommends using merino wool as a base layer. This material is warm, but wicks away sweat, she says.
Fit: Parents should also consider how a coat fits. A well-fitting coat will allow a child to move around and play. If the sleeves are creep up on the wrists, the coat is too small, McGurk says. If the sleeves are cover the hands, the coat is too big. Some coats have a clever extend-to-size feature, which allows you to snip some stitching to make the sleeves longer. Both McGurk and Yurich said they tend to go up one size to get two or more seasons out of a coat as well as to allow enough room for layers underneath. Sizing up can also help make the cost of a coat more reasonable.
Winter Coats and car seat safety
Parents should never size up when looking for a coat that’s safe to wear in a car seat. A large, thick coat can create as many as 3 to 4 inches of extra slack in the car seat straps. This increases the chances of injury in a car crash, explains Alisa Baer, cofounder of car seat safety advocacy organization The Car Seat Lady and a nationally certified child passenger safety instructor. The force of a car crash takes all the extra puff out of a coat. When that happens, the car seat straps or seat belt that once looked snug no longer fit properly and the child may move more in an accident or even slip out of the restraints.
To determine if a coat is safe for a car seat harness, use Baer’s Chalk Test (you can follow along with this video). With the child wearing the coat, buckle them into the seat and properly tighten the straps. Use a piece of chalk and mark where the tail strap — the strap that you pull to tighten the harness — comes out of the seat. Then remove the coat and buckle the child, tightening only to the chalk line. If you can pinch the straps or fit more than one finger underneath, then the coat is too bulky and should not be worn in the car seat.
Older children and even adults are also safest without buckling a seat belt over a bulky coat, Baer says. In the front seat, a belt tensioner locks in a crash, pulling the belt tight against the body. That removes the tension from the strap. However, most back seats do not have a belt tensioner, so coats will introduce extra slack. Even with a belt tensioner, all seat belts will work better without an overly large coat, Baer says.
Of course, cold is dangerous to a child as well, but the American Academy of Pediatrics says that a thin, snug-fitting coat such as a fleece jacket can be both safe in a crash and in the cold. A thin jacket along with a hat and gloves can keep a child warm when walking from the car to a building. Layering with a long-sleeve onesie and fleece leggings also helps, Baer says. Bring a warm winter coat to slip on over the fleece jacket for outdoor play or in the event the car breaks down.
Winter may be winding down, but thanks to off-season sales, now may be the perfect time to shop for next season’s coats. When shopping for a winter coat, it’s essential to keep your lifestyle and location in mind. Are you looking for a heavy-duty parka? Something stylish to keep you warm on your commute from the office to the train station? A full-on duffle coat for Arctic temperatures?
Because everyone has different needs, some might be on the hunt for a heavy-duty winter coat that’s both cozy and practical. Alternatively, others might be searching for a sophisticated wool coat that leans more into the overall look of the outfit. We know not every option on this list will appeal to everyone’s individual aesthetic, of course, but they will all keep you warm – and that’s pretty important. We also provide guidance on the types of insulation and fill power, which you can find following our product picks, to help you make a more informed decision. And while this guide focuses on coats sized for women, we believe anyone can wear any type of coat, regardless of gender. If you’re looking for men’s sizing, check out our guide to the best winter coats for men.
Here are 12 of the best winter coats for women:
The best technical winter coats
Insider
Fjällräven Singi Down Jacket
Backcountry
The foundation of what makes the so sturdy is that it’s constructed from the brand’s signature G-1000 — a densely woven polyester/cotton fabric that’s finished with Greenland Wax for water-resistance, wind-resistance, and overall durability. Over the shoulders and backside, the jacket is made of extra-tough G-1000 HeavyDuty, so the areas that need to be the most water-resistant and abrasion-resistant will stay that way. The jacket is padded with ethically-produced down, which not only keeps you incredibly warm on seriously cold days, but provides that snug-as-a-bug comfort.
Despite being incredibly toasty, the jacket’s cut is fitted but not restricting. There’s even an inner drawstring to create a more accented waist. The detachable faux-fur, down-filled hood looks stylish while keeping snow out of your face and your ears warm. Insider Reviews health and fitness updates editor Rachael Schultz has worn this jacket for many years now. She says it has kept her warm and dry in every kind of winter weather, whether it’s New York sleet or single-digit Colorado mornings.
Singi Down Jacket (button) Tna The Super Puff Long
Aritzia
The Super Puff Long is made with 100% responsibly-sourced goose down that’s meant to keep you warm to -40 degrees Fahrenheit. The nylon exterior is wind-resistant and water-repellent, but not fully waterproof. It boasts a hood and cozy lined pockets that add some extra comfort and style, too. There’s also a small interior pocket for your iPhone. And while it will surely keep you warm, the coat itself isn’t too heavy.
One of the usual pain points with ankle-length coats is that they can make it hard to walk if they’re zipped all the way down. The Super Puff Long solves that problem with a smart design — the zipper only goes to your knees. There are also buttons on the front and side of the coat that can be left open, allowing for more mobility. Insider Reviews deputy editor Sally Kaplan says it’s the warmest winter coat out there that isn’t a true parka. We also love the range of chic colors and finishes.
The Super Puff Long (button) Everlane The ReNew Long Puffer
Everlane
If you’re not a fan of down, opt for Everlane’s The ReNew Long Puffer. The entire coat, aside from the zipper and the trim, is made from recycled material — specifically recycled bottles. The only reason the zipper and trim aren’t recycled? They currently can’t be sourced from these materials, although the brand says it’s working on it.
Don’t think that the plastic makes this coat stiff, though. It’s as puffy, soft, and warm as traditional down. Everlane says the coat is recommended for temperatures between 15 and 30 degrees Fahrenheit. The ReNew Long Puffer hits about mid-thigh to the knee, depending on your height, so you get a good amount of leg coverage. And while it isn’t bulky, this coat has enough weight to it to keep you nice and toasty. Plus, the two large pockets are lined with fleece that make warming your hands and storing your essentials easy. And if you don’t love this silhouette, Everlane has a whole collection made from recycled plastic bottles.
ReNew Long Puffer (button) Orolay Thickened Down Jacket
Orolay
It’s likely you’ve heard of the Orolay Thickened Down Jacket. Dubbed “the Amazon coat” at the height of its internet fame, this cozy coat is a hit with its fans and a number of fashion experts. This puffer coat has a “downtown cool” silhouette, with a high-low hemline and oversized front pockets. It’s well priced for a 90% duck down jacket that will actually keep you pretty warm. It’s not the winter coat you’ll want to wear in extreme cold weather, but it’s certainly snug enough for the walk from the train to your front door.
Insider Reviews editor Maria Del Russo took her Orolay Jacket on a weekend trip during a cold snap and was surprised by how toasty it kept her. She appreciated the multiple pockets and the ribbed cuffs, which kept the wind from whipping up her arms. It’s worth mentioning, though, that it is not completely waterproof, so you’ll probably want something else for rainstorms or intense snow.
Thickened Down Jacket (button) Patagonia Down With It Parka
Backcountry
For a more sustainable insulated jacket, the Down With It Parka is one to watch. It’s made of 100% recycled polyester and the filling is composed of 100% recycled down, specifically reclaimed duck and goose down. The parka is also Fair Trade Certified sewn. Patagonia pays an additional fee for their products that don Fair Trade certified labels, and that sum goes directly to the workers in the factory. You can flaunt this parka knowing it was made under fair conditions and with sustainable materials.
But that doesn’t take away from its effectiveness in keeping you nice and warm. The detachable insulated hood is also a bonus feature. You should note, though, that this winter parka is meant to have a slim fit. So, if you prefer your jackets not to feel extra roomy or look super boxy, this one’s slim fit is ideal.
Down With It Parka (button) Eddie Bauer Lodge Down Duffle Coat
Eddie Bauer
Decked out head to knee in down insulation, the Lodge Down Duffle Coat is certainly one of our longest picks — falling past the knees — which means it’s also one of our warmest selections, too. While the Eddie Bauer StormRepel Durable Water Repellent resists moisture, the 650 fill power Responsible Down Standard keeps you cozy. The fleece lining of the upper body, collar, and cuffs offers up extra warmth and protection. Plus, you can customize different looks with the removable hood and faux fur trim, or you can cinch in at the waist using the drawstring cord. The two external pockets along with the one internal pocket fasten with zippers, so you know your belongings are safe.
Lodge Down Duffle Coat (button) Everlane The Re:Down Military Parka
Everlane
Warm and with lots of pockets, Everlane’s The Re:Down Military Parka is a fantastic option for super cold weather. The pockets are fleece-lined for extra warmth, the sleeves have cuffs to keep the wind from whipping up your arms, and the fill is made from recycled down. This parka is better suited for city wear than for serious outdoor activities, so if you’re not planning on snowshoeing or ice fishing, this will likely work fine for you. Insider Reviews style and beauty guides editor Maria Del Russo enjoys wearing this jacket and can vouch for its warmth, comfort, and style.
The Re:Down Military Parka (button) The best fashion winter coats
Insider
Everlane The Italian ReWool Overcoat
Everlane
Everlane’s Italian ReWool Overcoat has a subtle elegance and a weighty wool construction at a more budget-friendly price point. Like the rest of the ReNew line, Everlane’s The Italian ReWool Overcoat is made with recycled materials — 62% recycled wool and 38% recycled nylon, according to the company. It has a simple, oversized fit with thoughtful details like a notched collar and double-breasted front. Its rounded silhouette looks great buttoned up over jeans and a sweater on fall days or unbuttoned with a dress in more moderate temperatures. The inside is also lined, so you don’t have to worry about any itching if you’re sensitive to wool. Insider Reviews senior reporter Mara Leighton wears this coat frequently and recommends sizing down unless you have particularly long arms — she noted the sleeves were a bit short.
The Italian ReWool Overcoat (button) Babaton The Connor Coat Long
Aritzia
Coats can oftentimes have an oversized fit and therefore lack any sort of shape. Cinching your waist in with a belt is the perfect way to give some structure to your look — and in a flattering way at that. The Connor Coat Long pulls out all the stops, from the removable belt to the warm Italian wool. One of the more eye-catching elements is the asymmetrical cut of the closure, which keeps your neck snug, but also adds a chic flair. The coat is fully lined with vegan suede, and yes, there are pockets on each side.
Babaton The Connor Coat Long (button) Cuyana Wool Cashmere Short Wrap Coat
Cuyana
Another style that doesn’t go out of fashion is the wrap coat. It’s sophisticated and compliments your figure with a belt. This coat in particular makes its mark with the oversized lapels. You’ll find many wrap coats stick to regular-sized lapels, but this one’s bold choice provides extra warmth and elegance. And instead of falling past your knees, it cuts off right at your knees, enabling easy movement. The wool is also Responsible Wool Standard certified, meaning the material is ethically sourced.
Wool Cashmere Short Wrap Coat (button) The North Face 1996 Retro Nuptse Jacket
The North Face
A crossover between technical and fashion, the puffer jacket is everywhere. This one fits in both categories because it’s functional for moderate cold weather, but also sports one of the most popular jacket styles. For the technical side, it crops short, so it’s not really meant for the extreme cold, but it’s great for the fall-winter transition and springtime. The insulation will keep you warm with its 700 fill power goose down and water repellent material. And it’s very functional because the jacket can be folded into itself for compact storage, while a stowable hood packs into the collar.
In terms of fashion, this offering from puts retro style front and center, especially with the short, boxy silhouette and bright color block design. If you want the jacket to be even more form-fitting, you can adjust the bungee cinch at the hem.
Sometimes, simplicity is best. You can’t go wrong with a wool blend coat that falls right above your knees, has standard-sized lapels, and dons the conventional three-button setup. The relaxed fit allows for layering while still looking composed. Material-wise, this coat offers moderate warmth — you can layer up for the winter or keep it loose during the spring. The wool blend is double faced for added warmth, and it’s also unlined. This classic style is a wardrobe staple that can pair with anything from a chunky sweater and jeans in colder weather to a short dress in warmer temperatures.
Part of the problem with finding a great winter coat? It’s really hard to tell whether a jacket will be warm enough for the dead of winter until you’re actually wearing it in the dead of winter. Sure, the coat may seem cozy from the comfort of a dressing room. But is it really going to stand up to subzero temps once you bring it outside?
When shopping for a winter coat, it’s essential to keep your lifestyle and location in mind. Are you looking for a heavy-duty parka? Something stylish to keep you warm from the office to the train station? A full-on duffle coat for Arctic temperatures?
Regardless, you won’t have to sacrifice style. It’s certainly possible to both be warm and look cool at the exact same time. Not every option on this list will appeal to everyone’s individual aesthetic, of course, but they will all keep you warm without forgoing fashion. And that’s pretty important. We have guidance on the types of insulation and fill power below our picks to help you make a more informed decision.
A note on fit
This guide is specifically focused on coats that were designed with cisgender women in mind. The industry distinguishes between men and women’s coats in the details, specifically the fit and style. Coats designed for women tend to be nipped in at the waist, and even the oversized options have slightly shorter hemline and sleeves.
Women’s coats also tend to be a little more generously cut in the chest, while men’s coats are broader in the shoulders and back. And while zipper placement used to indicate whether a coat was designed for a man or woman, with the rise of more unisex styles, this is no longer a sure bet. If you’re looking for coats with longer sleeves or broader shoulders, you may want to shop for winter coats designed for men.
Updated by Maria Del Russo on 11/12/2020: Updated prices and links. Added a “what else we considered” slide with coats we love but that didn’t nab a top spot.
After careful editorial consideration (and debate), our editorial team has decided to discontinue our recommendations for fur products. While some of these brands in this guide still carry fur, we chose to solely test fur-free products. We’ll continue to test more fur- and down-free parkas throughout the winter in our ongoing search for the perfect winter coats.
The best winter parka
Askov Finlayson
The is expedition-grade, climate-positive, made out of recycled materials, and totally worth the hype.
Pros: Waterproof, carbon positive brand
Cons: One color option
Sizing options: S-XL
When looking for a great winter parka, we’re looking for pieces that are more practical than pretty. After all, when the temperatures drop below zero you’re going to want a coat that keeps you seriously warm and dry. The does that and even more.
Askov Finlayson is based in Minneapolis, Minnesota, a city known for its cold climate, so you already know that this jacket is going to be the real deal. To make the coat, Eric Dayton, co-founder of Askov Finlayson, studied the personal outerwear collection of famed Arctic explorer Will Steger. He used these learnings to develop the expedition-grade Winter Parka.
The is water-resistant and rated as comfortable all the way to 20-degrees below. It’s made from 3M’s proprietary Thinsulate material (a 100% recycled featherless insulation), a 100% recycled polyester shell, and an ultra-soft 100% bluesign certified micro ripstop taffeta lining. It’s got a scuba-fit hood to protect you from the elements, an insulated interior collar, and adjustable exterior cuffs.
There are plenty of pockets, both internal and external, to keep your valuables within arm’s reach. The Afield Pocket is probably one of the most unique additions — it features Present Mode technology, which blocks all cell and WiFi signals to help wearers stay present. One of the best parts is the whole entire jacket is machine-washable.
All of this, along with Askov Finlayson’s commitment to being carbon positive, will cost you $495. While this is certainly a big expense, it’s about half the price of some of the other popular parkas out there like Canada Goose.
Since this is a pricier piece, we appreciate that gives shoppers a whole winter to try out the parka. Don’t like it? You can return it with no questions asked. After that, there’s a limited lifetime warranty.
The best for serious winter weather
Moosejaw
Fjällräven’s Singi Down Jacket has every single feature you need to weather a real winter storm and will last you for years — if not decades.
Pros: Proprietary G-1000 fabric is water-resistant, wind-resistant, and durable; sustainably-sourced down; flattering fit; convenient pockets; two-way zipper; made for longevity
Cons: None to speak of
Sure, this jacket is expensive — there’s no getting around that fact. But that’s because Fjällräven has a long-standing commitment to sustainability, including using recycled, organic, and sustainably-sourced materials to create pieces that can be worn for years. So while you’re paying a huge chunk now, this jacket is crafted to keep you warm and dry for decades. And because the Singi has every single feature you need for nasty weather in a flattering cut, you really won’t need to buy any other jacket.
The foundation of what makes Fjällräven’s Singi so sturdy is that it’s constructed from the brand’s signature G-1000 — a densely woven polyester/cotton fabric that is finished with Greenland Wax for water-resistance, wind-resistance, and overall durability. Over the shoulders and backside, the jacket is made of extra-tough G-1000 HeavyDuty, so the areas that need to be the most water-resistant and abrasion-resistant will stay that way. The jacket is padded with ethically-produced down, which not only keeps you incredibly warm on seriously cold days, but provides that snug-as-a-bug comfort.
Despite being incredibly toasty, the jacket’s cut is fitted but not restricting. There is even an inner drawstring to create a more accented waist. The detachable faux-fur, down-filled hood looks stylish while keeping blowing snow out of your face and your ears nice toasty. I’ve owned this jacket for four years, and it has kept me seriously warm and completely dry in every kind of winter weather — from New York sleet to cold, single-digit Colorado mornings. — Rachael Schultz
The best lightweight coat
Uniqlo
The Uniqlo Ultra Light Down Parka is small but mighty — it can roll up into a little ball that fits in your pocket while still providing substantial warmth.
Pros: Packable, affordable, great for travel
Cons: Not the warmest on this list, not waterproof
Sizing options: XXS-XXL
Warm coats don’t always have to be super heavy. The Uniqlo Ultra Light Down Parka is my favorite option for a lightweight coat that also keeps you warm. When you’re not wearing the coat, you can roll it up and put it in the accompanying storage pouch. The fact that it’s so packable makes it pretty much a no-brainer for travel.
The Ultra Light Down Parka is surprisingly warm for how thin it looks and how airy it feels. Still, I wouldn’t rely on it as my only option for extreme cold. But, because it’s not bulky, you can easily throw it under a heavier coat for an added layer of warmth. You could also size up in order to squeeze a few extra layers under this coat.
In terms of the construction, the Ultra Light Down Parka has a down fill and a nylon shell. The exterior is water-repellent, but not fully waterproof. While it’s pretty durable for flurries, if you get caught in a serious snowstorm or rain shower you can expect the coat to get wet. I like the hooded option as it feels most practical for cold weather, but Uniqlo offers ones without hoods too.
Because it can be squished down and becomes so small, I find myself wearing it all the time. Whether it’s layered under a heavier jacket, over a t-shirt and sweater, or just worn on its own, I wear this coat pretty much every season — except summer, of course.
The best ankle-length coat
Aritzia
The Super Puff Long keeps your legs covered for warmth while also giving you the freedom to move comfortably.
Pros: Stylish, lots of color options, freedom to move
Cons: Not waterproof
Sizing options: 3XS-XL
On really cold days, the more covered you are the better. That’s when an ankle-length coat, like the Tna Super Puff, comes in. It’s a puffy down jacket that comes in multiple colors and lengths, but we’re partial to the long version.
The Super Puff Long is made with 100% responsibly-sourced goose down that’s meant to keep you warm to -40 degrees Fahrenheit. The nylon exterior is wind-resistant and water-repellent, but not fully waterproof. It boasts a hood and cozy lined pockets that add some extra comfort and style, too. There’s also a small interior pocket made to hold your iPhone securely. And while it will surely keep you warm, the coat itself isn’t too heavy.
One of the usual pain points with ankle-length coats is that they can make it hard to walk if they’re zipped all the way down. The Super Puff Long solves that problem with a smart design — the zipper only goes to your knees. There are also buttons on the front and side of the coat that can be left open, allowing for more mobility.
Insider Reviews senior editor Sally Kaplan says it’s the warmest winter coat out there that isn’t a true parka. We also love the range of chic colors and finishes.
The best down-alternative coat
Everlane
The Everlane ReNew Long Puffer is made from recycled materials, but you can still expect the same warmth as a classic down coat.
Pros: Sustainably made, good price, very warm
Cons: Limited color options, exterior pockets don’t zip
Sizing options: XXS-XL
If you’re not a fan of down, opt for Everlane’s ReNew Long Puffer. The entire coat, aside from the zipper and the trim, is made from recycled material — specifically recycled bottles. The only reason the zipper and trim aren’t recycled? They currently can’t be sourced from these materials — although the brand says it’s working on it.
Don’t think that the plastic makes this coat stiff, though. It’s as puffy, soft, and warm as traditional down. Everlane says the coat is recommended for temperatures between 15 and 30 degrees Fahrenheit. The ReNew Long Puffer hits about mid-thigh to the knee, depending on your height, so you get a good amount of leg coverage. And while it isn’t bulky, this coat has enough weight to it to keep you nice and toasty.
I really appreciate the thoughtful design, too. While the jacket went all the way down to just above my knees, the zipper doesn’t zip to the bottom, so you can walk without your legs feeling constrained. The hood has drawstrings so you can keep your head warm on windy, chilly days. There are also two large, convenient pockets lined with cozy fleece that make it easy to store essentials in the jacket — all while keeping your hands nice and warm.
The Orolay Thickened Down Jacket lives up to its internet buzz, providing warmth and style at a budget-friendly price.
Pros: Stylish, affordable, warm
Cons: Not waterproof
Sizing options: XXS-5XL. Fits true to size, and the coat is roomy enough for you to wear a sweater under.
It’s likely that you’ve heard of the Orolay Thickened Down Jacket. Dubbed “the Amazon coat” at the height of its internet fame, this cozy coat is a hit with its fans and a number of fashion experts. And trust me, it lives up to the buzz.
This puffer coat has a “downtown cool” silhouette, with a high-low hemline and oversized front pockets. It’s well priced for a 90% duck down jacket that will actually keep you pretty warm. It’s not the winter coat you’ll want to wear in extreme cold, but it’s certainly cozy enough for the walk from the train to your front door.
Insider Reviews editor Maria Del Russo took her Orolay Jacket on a weekend trip during a cold snap and was surprised by how toasty warm it kept her. She appreciated the multiple pockets and the ribbed cuffs, which kept the wind from whipping up her arms.
This coat has been compared to the more expensive options from Canada Goose, which usually are over five times the price of the Orolay Thickened Down Jacket. It’s worth mentioning that it is not waterproof, so you’ll probably want something else for rainstorms or intense snow.
The best wool coat
Everlane
Made of recycled Italian wool, Everlane’s Italian ReWool Overcoat has a clean finish and a double-face for added warmth with a premium feel.
Pros: Good price for the quality, versatile fit, warm
Cons: Oversized, you may need to size down
Sizing options: 00-16
A great wool coat elevates any outfit and keeps you cozy while doing so, but a well-made one can be pricy. Everlane’s Italian ReWool Overcoat has a subtle elegance and a weighty wool construction at a more budget-friendly price point.
Like the rest of the ReNew line, the Italian ReWool Overcoat is made with recycled materials — 62% recycled wool and 38% recycled nylon, according to the company. It has a simple, oversized fit with thoughtful details like a notched collar and double-breasted front. Its rounded silhouette that looks great buttoned up over a dress or unbuttoned with jeans and a tee.
For fall days, it’s warm enough worn on its own. When it gets chillier, there’s room to layer heavier tops underneath. The inside is also lined, so you don’t have to worry about any itching if you’re sensitive to wool.
Insider Reviews senior reporter Mara Leighton wears this coat frequently and recommends sizing down unless you have particularly long arms — she noted the sleeves were a bit short.
Other coats we considered
Everlane
Everlane The Re:Down Military Parka ($198): Warm and with lots of pockets, Everlane’s The Re:Down Military Parka is a fantastic option for super cold weather. The pockets are fleece-lined for extra warmth, the sleeves have cuffs to keep the wind from whipping up your arms, and the fill is made from recycled down. The shell is also totally weatherproof — perfect for rain and snow. But as far as heavy-duty parkas go, the Askov Finlayson just wins out, as it’s better suited as performance wear. That said, Everlane’s parka is better suited for city wear than for serious outdoor activities, so if you’re not planning on snowshoeing or ice fishing, this will likely work fine for you.
Daily Ritual Women’s Relaxed-Fit Mock-Neck Short Puffer Jacket ($64): If you’re in need of an easy, toss-on-and-go short puffer jacket, this option is a great buy for the price. For $64, this jacket is puffy, warm, and boasts a super cute, oversized collar for extra warmth. The Daily Ritual coat is also machine washable, which not many winter coats can claim. The one drawback we couldn’t get over, though, was the pockets. There are only two and they’re entirely too shallow, which makes it a frustrating piece to wear for errands.
Goodthreads Women’s Relaxed Fit Sherpa Long Sleeve Snap Front Coat ($67.50): While it’s not great as a winter coat on its own, this adorable sherpa coat is a great transitional jacket and can be worn as a layer when it gets chilly. Its longline silhouette and snap-button closure make for a chic piece of outerwear, and the sherpa ensures you’ll stay warm — whether this is a lightweight coat in the fall or as a shell piece under something warmer. Since it’s not heavy enough to be a winter coat on its own, we couldn’t give it a spot in this guide. But it’s amazing for layering and for transitional weather, so it’s worth picking up.
Things to keep in mind while shopping for women’s winter coats
Everlane
Types of insulation:
Down: Still the most popular fill for winter coats, down is the name for the fluffy layer of under-feathers harvested from ducks and geese. That fluffiness serves a purpose: down has thousands of tiny air pockets that trap and retain heat, keeping the wearer warm. It’s also ultra-compressible, lightweight, and breathable.
However, down loses its insulating powers when it becomes wet, and it can take a while to dry out. Plus, lower-quality down can harbor dust and debris, triggering allergies in those who are sensitive to such things.
Down can be harvested using different methods, and some are more ethical than others. Some brands even repurpose old, recycled down in an effort to be sustainable. We have chosen to keep down recommendations in this guide, but have offered great down-free alternatives if that is how you prefer to shop.
Water-resistant down: No down filling is completely water-resistant, but polymer-treated down is definitely better at wicking away moisture. It also tends to be very expensive and still doesn’t handle dampness as effectively as synthetic insulation.
Synthetic insulation: Made from a combination of water-resistant compressed fibers, synthetic insulation mimics down in its ability to trap warm air via tiny holes. Synthetics are often heavier than down, and they’re not quite as compressible. But on the upside, they dry faster and are often significantly less expensive. Some common synthetic fills include Thinsulate, Polarguard, Thermolite, Dryloft, and Hollofil.
Down/synthetic insulation: These coats mix both materials throughout or are designed so that some areas are down-filled (like the core) and others (the arms, for example) contain synthetic insulation.
A word on fill power:
Down is rated according to fill power, which is represented by the number of cubic inches one ounce of down occupies. To test it, the down is compressed by a weight in a glass cylinder and then allowed to bounce back. The better the quality of down, the higher the fill power, with numbers typically ranging from 300 to 900. Down outerwear typically falls between 600 and 800, with anything higher considered premium.
